For immediate release -- Wednesday, March 22, 2006
Contact Bob Brammer - 515-281-6699
Court Okays Largest Consumer Restitution in Iowa
Ameriquest Mortgage must reform lending practices and pay $325 million --
including $2 million to Iowans.
DES MOINES. Attorney General Tom Miller announced today that the Polk County District Court has approved a
judgment ordering Ameriquest Mortgage Company, the nation's largest sub-prime lender, to pay $295 million to
consumers and make sweeping reforms of practices that states alleged amounted to predatory lending.
"Iowa consumers are expected to receive about $2 million in the settlement," Miller said. "It's the largest consumer
restitution in state history."
Miller said court
filings yesterday formalized an agreement between states and Ameriquest
that was announced in January. Iowa's lawsuit
was filed Tuesday alleging consumer fraud and other violations by Ameriquest,
and a Consent Judgment was then presented
for Court approval of the settlement. District Court Judge John D. Lloyd
approved the Consent Judgment.
Similar court action yesterday was expected in states all over the U.S. Ameriquest also will pay a total of $30 million to 49
states and D.C. that are participating in the settlement.
"We alleged that Ameriquest engaged in unfair and deceptive practices that harmed consumers," Miller said at a news
briefing in Des Moines. "This is a landmark agreement that will change Ameriquest's practices, and it will set standards
we expect other mortgage lenders to follow."
Miller said the $325 million nationwide total Ameriquest payment ranks as the second-largest state or federal consumer
protection settlement in history, after the $484 million predatory lending agreement reached in 2002 between most states
and Household Finance Corporation, another multi-state investigation and settlement led by Miller. Iowa consumers
received about $1.3 million in the Household case.
In the Ameriquest case, the states alleged that Ameriquest employees deceived consumers as part of high-pressure tactics to
sell mortgage refinancings. They said high-pressure sales tactics were used to reach desired sales levels and high monthly
individual sales quotas.
Miller said Attorney Generals, financial regulators and California district attorneys initiated their investigation after
receiving hundreds of complaints from Ameriquest customers across the country. Improper practices alleged by the states
included: inadequate disclosure of prepayment penalties, discount points and other loan terms; improperly influencing and
accepting inflated appraisals; and encouraging borrowers to give inaccurate or inflated income or employment information
to obtain loans.
Ameriquest denies all the allegations raised by the states, but the company agreed to be bound by a battery of new
standards to prevent what the states alleged were unfair and deceptive practices. The reforms include: changing how
appraisals are handled; providing full disclosure regarding interest rates, discount points, prepayment penalties, and other
loan terms; and not paying incentives to sales personnel to include prepayment penalties or any other fees or charges in the
"We are confident Ameriquest will fully comply with our laws and regulations in the future," Miller said. "Ameriquest
already has instituted many changes, and an independent monitor will be watching company practices carefully. So will
Miller said the independent monitor approved by the States - led by former Mississippi Attorney General Mike Moore -
already has begun visits and reviews of Ameriquest activity.
Ameriquest primarily makes refinancing loans to existing homeowners who are hoping to consolidate credit card and other
debt into their mortgage and come out ahead with overall monthly savings. Borrowers who don't have the best credit
ratings may turn to sub-prime loans, which often have higher interest rates and other costs.
"Questionable practices in the sub-prime industry can be very harmful to ordinary consumers, who often have little or no
economic cushion," Miller said.
- 30 -
Background on the Ameriquest Agreement:
The settlement with the states includes ACC Capital Holding Corporation (the holding company), and its subsidiaries
Ameriquest Mortgage Company, Town & Country Credit Corporation, and AMC Mortgage Services, Inc., formerly known
as Bedford Home Loans. The company is based in Orange, California, near Los Angeles.
Forty-nine states are parties to the settlement, with both Attorneys General and financial regulators joining the settlement.
(Ameriquest was not licensed in Virginia and did no business there, so Virginia is not a party to the agreement.)
growth over the last few years has made Ameriquest the nation's largest sub-prime mortgage lender.
"We uncovered serious problems at Ameriquest that unfairly and substantially affected their borrowers," he said.
"However, now we have reached an agreement that will return hundreds of millions of dollars to consumers, and - even
more important - it will reform the company's practices. Indeed, I believe this agreement will fundamentally change the
company. I am grateful that Ameriquest has reached this agreement with us."
Terms of the Settlement and Injunctive Relief:
About half the 49-page agreement with the states spells out "injunctive relief" -- wide-ranging reforms of the company's
lending practices to resolve the concerns of the states.
Under the agreement, Ameriquest is required to:
- Provide the same
interest rates and discount points for similarly-situated consumers.
- Not pay incentives
to sales personnel to include prepayment penalties or any other fees
or charges in the mortgages.
- Provide full disclosure
regarding interest rates, discount points, prepayment penalties, and
other loan or refinancing terms.
- Overhaul its appraisal
practices by removing branch offices and sales personnel from the appraiser
selection process, instituting an automated system to select appraisers
from panels created in each state, limiting the company's ability to
get second opinions on appraisals, and prohibiting Ameriquest employees
from influencing appraisals.
- Not encourage prospective
borrowers to misstate income sources or income levels.
- Provide accurate,
good faith estimates.
- Limit prepayment
penalty periods on variable rate mortgages.
- Not engage in refinancing
solicitations during the first 24 months of a loan, unless the borrower
is considering refinancing.
- Use independent
- Adopt policies
to protect whistle-blowers and facilitate reporting of improper conduct.
The agreement also provides for appointment of an independent monitor to oversee Ameriquest's compliance with the
settlement terms. The monitor will have broad authority to examine Ameriquest's lending operations, including access to
documents and personnel. The monitor will submit periodic compliance reports to the Attorneys General during the next
five years. Ameriquest will pay the monitor's costs.
Payments by Ameriquest:
The company will pay $325 million - $295 million for consumer restitution, and $30 million to settling states to cover their
costs in the case and fund consumer education and consumer protection enforcement programs.
Consumers do not need to take any action at this point to pursue recoveries - they will be contacted later by states or the
settlement administrator in the months ahead as specific recovery terms and plans are determined.
Of the $295 million in restitution, $175 million will be distributed in a nationwide claims process to eligible Ameriquest
customers who obtained mortgages from January 1, 1999, through April 1, 2003, with payments based on a national
formula set by the settling states.
Another $120 million in restitution will be allocated to the settling states based on the percentage of total Ameriquest loans
(measured in dollars) held by consumers in each state. Iowa's share of the $120 million is $552,000. The funds will be
used to compensate Ameriquest customers who obtained mortgages between January 1, 1999, and December 31, 2005.
Each settling state will determine which customers in its jurisdiction are eligible to receive payments from this restitution
The States' Investigation:
Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller led the group of states. The group of states that negotiated the agreement are: the
attorney general offices of Iowa, California, Washington, New York, and Illinois; the New York State Department of
Banking; and California district attorneys. The executive committee of states leading the matter included those states and
also the attorney general offices of Minnesota, Arizona, Texas, Massachusetts, New Mexico, and Connecticut, and the
financial regulators of Washington, Nebraska, New Hampshire, and Florida. Miller said the Minnesota Attorney General's
Office played a strong early role in the matter, and Minnesota Assistant Attorney General Prentiss Cox led the group
initially. Since June 2005, Iowa Assistant Attorney General Patrick Madigan has led the group of assistant attorneys
general and financial regulators who investigated and negotiated with Ameriquest.
Miller said Ameriquest was forthcoming in providing documents and other information during the investigation and that
the states and Ameriquest worked extraordinarily long hours to reach the agreement.
The settlement was joined by officials of 49 states and the District of Columbia, and a group of six California District
Attorneys. (Virginia is not a party because Ameriquest did no business there.) Attorneys General for 49 states and DC
joined the agreement, as did financial regulators for 45 states and DC. In a few states, financial regulators did not
participate because they do not have jurisdiction, or no such regulator exists in the state.
Attorney General Home | News Release Home
© 2000 THE STATE OF IOWA. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.